Monday, February 28, 2011

What we've got here is a failure to communicate


     Because this blog was created as a component of a seminar course on effective communication of science to the public, it stands to reason that I should be reflecting on this topic regularly. Now, defining "the public" is not always easy, and I've used Joe T. Public as my all-encompassing stand in, but it seems that I often consider myself to be one of the public. If the public are simply people who are not experts (or nowhere near experts) on a subject, then when it comes to new-fangled CMSB (cellular, molecular, and structural biology), I consider myself one of the public. Sure, I've had a few introductory biology courses that do a brief survey of these fields, but I've never had an advanced course, and I certainly don't read the literature. So, when I go to see a talk by a professional scientist doing this kind of research, I take on the role of the public with whom the speaker should be effectively communicating.

     At the last CMSB talk I attended, I think I understood three of the presenter's slides. There were probably fifty or so presented in total. Included in the three I think I understood are the intro slide (Hi, this is my name and where I work) and the closing slide (Thanks for listening, here's the people who helped me). That leaves one actual slide that I think I understood. Isn't this a major problem?

     I've already prefaced this with my admitted ignorance on the entire field of biology in which this presentation fit, but does that mean that the speaker should avoid making any effort to communicate effectively with me? This talk was not given at a special gathering of experts in the field, but rather to an entire department that is (unfortunately) labeled "zoology". We've grappled in seminar about the importance of casting your talk at the right level for your audience, so why is it that this talk (and CMSB talks in general) fail to do so?

     My two guesses: 1) scientists trained in this field are never taught [i]how[/i] to communicate effectively with the public, and 2) the science in this field cannot be effectively communicated to the public. I've left out the cynical third guess that assumes the scientists just don't care, but this may be the case. If the problem is that there is no training for communication in this field, one has to wonder why that is the case. Surely all science deserves to be communicated to the public. Most of the CMSB talks I've been to relate fairly directly to human health in some way, so it would seem that these scientists would have much to gain from communicating with the public. They'll never have a hostile crowd at their lab door, wielding pitchforks and torches, demanding justification for the work being done there. Perhaps it is this very issue that makes them such poor communicators: their work relates so directly to human health, they only have to state as much to satisfy Joe T. Public. When that level of communication is the extent to which you flex your communication muscles, it's no wonder you fail so spectacularly when someone wants to know more than the superficial about your research.

     The second guess is obviously an exaggeration, but I think there is some truth to it. In my areas of interest (behavior and ecology), most concepts are fairly intuitive. Of course females will be more choosy than males when selecting mates, they (typically) invest far more in their offspring than the males. Is anyone confused about this? Doesn't it make sense that prey would change the kind of food they eat when predators are around? They should eat food that gives them more bang for their buck, since wasting time eating less nutritious food exposes them to risk of predation. Simple, right? Finally, a topic that ecologists often describe as "complex" is the trophic cascade. But here it is, plain and simple: If you eliminate bears, you get more deer, and more deer means fewer plants. Do I need to repeat that?

     I think one of the main challenges a CMSB scientist faces is that the concepts in their field do not clearly apply to intuitive relationships that the public can see in their daily lives. We pay zero attention to transcription, cell signaling, gene regulation, and ATP synthesis even though these things are going on inside the cells that compose our bodies all the time. The inner workings of the cell are more abstract that the inner workings of an ecosystem, though both can be complex. However, I do not think all complexity is created equal. Compare these diagrams:



On the top is a food web; each sphere represents an organism, and lines between spheres represent the fact that things eat each other. On the bottom is a diagram of signaling pathways within a cell, linking all the different molecules that interact with one another. Sure, both of these diagrams have a lot going on and would probably intimidate Joe T. Public. The point is that one of these can be effectively explained to anyone in a few sentences, and the other one takes an advanced degree to approach intellectually.

Naturally, my viewpoint is biased, but I have yet to attend a CMSB talk that effectively communicated with me (the public).

P.S. There is a curious lack of CMSB students in this seminar...

Friday, February 18, 2011

Stresses of being a working mother



While I don't actually have any insight into the topic of this post (as related to humans), I'd like to share some findings from the world of spiders.

     Daiqin Li and Robert Jackson published a paper a few years ago investigating the role of predation cues on parental care in a spider. The focal species, Scytodes pallida, is a spitting spider that ejects a mixture of silk and venom from its fangs. Scytodes females carry their egg sacs around in their chelicerae (the parts attached to the fangs) until the spiderlings hatch.

A female Scytodes carrying her egg sac in her chelicerae

     This is clearly awesome, but Scytodes has a problem: it is preyed upon by another spider called Portia labiata. Portia belongs to the jumping spider family, known for excellent vision and surprisingly sophisticated cognitive abilities. Portia has learned (over evolutionary time) to preferentially consume Scytodes that are carrying eggs. The benefits are two-fold: 1) Portia gets to eat the Scytodes mother and her eggs, and 2) Portia is more successful at capturing Scytodes, since the eggs must be dropped before defensive spitting can commence.

A menacing Portia, the spider that eats other spiders

     The question Li and Jackson were interested in is whether Scytodes has any way to resolve the conflict between needing to carry eggs and defend itself from Portia. The authors predict that Scytodes may change traits related to egg hatching in order to solve this problem.

     Egg-carrying Scytodes were presented with volatile chemical cues (basically, smells) left behind by Portia. These cues could come from silk, feces, or anything else the spider leaves behind. The authors measured the time until the eggs hatched, how big the spiderlings were, and the proportion of eggs that failed to develop. They found that eggs hatched sooner and produced smaller offspring when Portia cues were present (compared to a control without any Portia cues). What's even cooler is that this effect of shorter incubation and smaller offspring was even stronger if the Portia providing the cues had recently eaten Scytodes. Although there was no statistically significant effect on the proportion of eggs that failed to develop, the trend was the same as incubation time.

Eggs from females under risk of predation hatched sooner

     What this all means is that Scytodes can sense predator cues and respond by speeding up the development of its offspring. The benefit is that the sooner the egg sac is gone, the sooner Scytodes can defend itself from Portia. A potential cost is that the offspring will be smaller than usual, which may put them at a disadvantage later in life. Presumably, this is better than getting eaten before the spiderlings even get to hatch. What a tough world these spiders live in! If only they could invent spider day care.

     Just how Scytodes changes the incubation time is not known, but this just demonstrates how science works. An observation leads to a question, and the answer to that question creates more questions. Scientists never stop questioning, and it seems like we may never run out of mysteries to solve. How's that for job security?

Friday, February 11, 2011

Obviously, this is our future...





Sampling some of the attempts to communicate a very complex science (climate change) to non-scientists (the ever-present Joe Public) reveals fundamental challenges in trying to make a point.


A Newsweek article takes the informed approach by stating that "global warming" is more than just a uniform increase in temperature across the globe. Furthermore, the author argues that extreme weather events cannot be blamed on climate change, since these events are products of local phenomena (e.g., air masses colliding). The real evidence comes from long term trends, though the wealth of data going back hundreds of thousands of years is curiously never mentioned.


I can't help but feel like the reader is walking into a bait-and-switch situation here: climate change is real and happening, but nothing we observe on a daily basis can be attributed to it. This seems like a great way to disconnect human behavior from larger processes, which is exactly the opposite of what we should be trying to accomplish. The author tangles with some real science-type words by writing about “a high pressure system that has intensified an average of 0.9 geopotential meters every decade over the past 60 years”. Knowing that this kind of language would be lost on readers (why even use it?), the author translates into "layman terms". I wonder if this strategy is ineffective: layman is defined as someone lacking knowledge. What is the value in trying to communicate like this?


The conclusion of this article is especially terrible. Climate scientists at Duke are portrayed as having given u the search for a "natural" explanation for their data and then fallen back on the last remaining explanation of human-induced change. I sincerely doubt this is the method by which the scientists did their study. The author fails to end with any advice about what can be done, and instead seems to suggest that we should just strap in and enjoy the ride. Who knows what's coming next with all this wacky global weirding!?


Two articles from Time magazine, from 2006 and 2010, illustrate more issues in communicating this important message to Joseph T. Public. The first of these contradicts a main message from the Newsweek article by attributing a series of extreme weather events directly to global warming. Now Joe doesn't know what to think, because even the journalists can't decide how to interpret our world! While the analogy of earth as a living organism is childish and stupid, the author at least takes the time to highlight the nature of some of the changes going on: glacial melting, release of soil carbon, ocean conveyor belts, and drought. The author likely alienated a number of readers by overly politicizing the end of the article, in a section titled "What we can do" (which, incidentally, gives no advice about what we can do).


In 2006, it seemed that many skeptics had been convinced that climate change was real, but the story is very different in 2010. The author points out how scare tactics ("I have a nightmare" vs. "I have a dream"), may be responsible for the loss of public belief in climate change. This approach relates back (again) to the deficit model: Joe will not be convinced by all them crazy datas; scientists need to appeal to his values. There's some oddness in here about people who believe the world is a just place, but I'm not sure how that fits with the story being told here. Is there any hope in communicating a message to someone who believes the world is a just place? If it is, then why do anything? Justice will sort it out, right?


The author concludes that the public can't be won over by scare tactics, though active mis-information (i.e., lies) are incredibly effective. The solution for scientists is thus made entirely clear: stop scaring people with reality, and start lying to them about a fantasy land of musical rainbows and chocolate snowflakes. Hooray!


Thursday, February 3, 2011

On becoming a more best writer


     Here I comment on two selections from a book called The Best Science Writing of 2010, both focused on the consequences of what we eat. Before I delve into each article, consider the initial approach of both. In All You Can Eat, Jim Carrier begins with, “The green dumpster behind Red Lobster was nearly empty when I lifted the lid”. In Graze Anatomy, Richard Manning begins, “Will Winter and Todd Churchill have a plan”. Unless you are borderline comatose, how do you put these articles down after reading the first sentence? What is this guy doing in the dumpster, and what are those two planning? Now consider the first sentence from one of the peer-reviewed scientific publications currently sitting on my desk. In an article titled “Interactions of multiple predators with different foraging modes in an aquatic food web”, Michael Carey & David Wahl begin with, “Predation is a key factor structuring communities and drives food web dynamics”. Are you holding your breath? Where could this gripping story lead? Obviously the selections from the book and the peer-reviewed paper have different goals and different audiences, but I wasn't surprised to see that the selections from the book were not peer-reviewed journal articles. The best science writing is apparently taking place outside of where most scientists do their writing, an eerie parallel to the issue of where the public does their learning about science (see my previous post titled Communicating ecological issues with the public).

All You Can Eat – Jim Carrier


     This article tackles issues surrounding the source of our food, namely shrimp. The sustainability of the (largely former) shrimp catching industry and the pitfalls of the (now dominant) shrimp farming industry are brought into the light. While I did not need to read this article to be convinced of the sorry state of the seafood industry (I already read the marvelous and depressing book, The Empty Ocean), Carrier likely converted a number of people to swearing off shrimp (or at least consuming them more responsibly). Take a moment to appreciate that he might not have had as many readers had he started his article with, “Shrimp are an essential component of the human diet and benthic marine community”.

     Some of the essential characteristics of Carrier's writing that likely got it included in this compendium are his use of story telling, character development, dialogue/quotations, scenery descriptions, pacing, approachable language, and interesting jumps in time and space. Now, I haven't taken a introduction to writing course or anything comparable, but these characteristics appear in most of the things I read (scientific articles excluded). A non-scientist friend of mine pointed out that people who are good at doing science writing are probably good writers in general, with an interest in science. I agreed, and it stands to reason that a grip on the essential elements of good writing in general will translate to good science writing.

     I'm not sure what criteria were used to label these selections as “best”, but I doubt they put much weight on the effectiveness with which the author communicates science. Yes, it is an entertaining read, but will readers come away understanding the science? I already feel myself slipping into deficit thinking, wherein communicating science requires nothing more than spouting facts and figures. Carrier gets the point across that the fisheries are in serious trouble, and even takes the time to give an overview of shrimp biology. Is this enough to get the public to understand the science? Where are the models for maximum sustainable yield that I had to program by hand during my course in population and community ecology? Coding and manipulating those models got me to understand the underlying science, but we can't really expect the public to take the same approach.

     Carrier excels by making the scientific issues relevant to the public by tying in other subjects (politics, history, economics) and making it clear how this relates to everyday life (choosing a restaurant, being a more responsible consumer). I hope that this mode of effectiveness (re: making people care) was an important criterion in choosing which articles would appear in this book.



     Richard Manning, author of Graze Anatomy, highlights the benefits and future of the grass-fed beef movement. I was also familiar with this topic from the various Pollan-related media I've come in contact with. A fellow graduate student, Tim Bankroff, works in this field, and we've shared a few discussions on the topic. The punchline of the story is similar to Carrier's: we can improve the quality of life on this planet if we change the way we produce our food. Manning is also effective at including just enough science to substantiate his claims without drowning the reader in the details. Economic tie-ins feature prominently in this piece, and the link to global warming is unavoidable. These issues engage the public in ways that an ANOVA table displaying a significant interaction between cow food and grazing area simply cannot. I felt that Manning fell short in terms of writing quality, as his piece lacked the upbeat pace and interesting characters found in All You Can Eat.

     Overall, it seems that being the best writer takes a grasp on the fundamentals of writing combined with insight into how to make your audience care about what you are writing. I think these are two different skill sets, and I'll echo my previous thought by suggesting that scientists recruit these authors to help the public understand the meaning and value of the science that we do.

Friday, January 28, 2011

Blogging about blogging

     Comparing different approaches to communicating science raises some interesting questions, the most important of which deals with the very existence of science blogs. What is the purpose of a science blog? While I don't have the answer, an overview of a selection of blogs may be a good starting point in resolving this question.

     Since I'm listening to the radio program right now, I'll begin with the Science Friday blog. This blog complements the radio program and is regularly updated. SciFri frequently blends topics like technology, internet security, and economics with scientific issues. While the blog is not disconnected from basic research (the authors do interpret primary literature), the focus is certainly more on the applied side of science. SciFri seems to be avoiding the pitfalls of the deficit model (belief that getting the public to understand scientific issues means forcing data down their throats), because the authors strive to relate these issues to "the real world" and the comings and going of our daily lives.

     In stark contrast to SciFri, there is Parasite of the Day. This small-scale blog highlighted a parasite a day for an entire year and is now updated less vigorously. The goal of the blog seems to be communicating science for the sake of sharing information. The contributors have no real agenda beyond highlighting interesting organisms people would not normally hear about. How does this apply to anyone who is not infected with some exotic organism? Knowledge for the sake of knowledge is fine by me, but this blog seems to have a limited audience, and the lack of any applied angle, may prevent people from ever caring about the content. And yet, I think it is quite admirable to undertake a project like this just to share enthusiasm about a subject you find interesting.

     Another low-profile blog, Marine Conservation News takes a very different approach to communicating science than Parasite of the Day. The authors' focus is entirely applied, and relate content to their readers that highlight the current state of marine conservation. Their informed opinions, make the content highly approachable for the general public, despite the fact that the blog does not have many readers. While the blog doesn't really communicate science in a primary sense (interpreting journal articles), it does spread awareness of conservation issues that are ultimately related to current scientific endeavors. The blog may be more successful than others in that it often provides outlets for its readers to participate in marine conservation.

     Leaving the realm of small, personal blogs takes us to Scientists at Work, which is a component of the NY Times. The blog takes the form of field notes, sharing with the public what it is like to actually do science. Obviously, someone at the Times thought the public would actually care to read about this. It can be a bit tedious to read, but by humanizing the scientific process (and scientists) the blog helps to break the traditional (mis)conception of Bunsen burners, beakers, and lab coats being the defining characteristics of science. Readers of this blog learn about how research is done, but is this really a way of communicating science?

     From personalized accounts of science research, I next move to comment on the cleverly-titled blog The EEB & Flow. This blog is dedicated to interpreting current work in ecology and evolutionary biology, and features numerous authors who provide quality insight into a diversity of articles. This blog doesn't seem to work for the general public, as the material is often too dense and jargon-laden. However, this only makes me question the idea of what defines "the public". There are a number of graduate students in my department who have a general background in ecology and evolution, though they are not specialists in the field. We can read this blog and get something meaningful out of it, so I think that we are "the public" for this blog. The blog post about children scientists is fitting, as it questions what it is that defines a scientist. The same issue arises with defining the public, and I think it would be safest to avoid formulating any strict rules regarding either term. Unlike Scientists at Work, this blog is very impersonal and is therefore more in line with the normal means by which scientists communicate their work. This is not to say that one method is better or worse than the other, and the blog entry regarding the bacteria-arsenic controversy raises some interesting ideas about scientific communication in the modern age. Would it even be possible for scientists to move the peer review process to an online open forum, where hypotheses and data live and die by group consensus? Would scientists even bother to participate in this activity?

     Last, but not least, is Zooillogix. Taking a humorous approach to communicating science, this blog shares a general wonder about the natural world while occasionally delving into primary literature. The incorporation of humor, personal asides, and media (youtube features prominently in this blog) may make this blog more approachable than many of the above. If most Americans are learning about science outside of the classroom, one has to wonder if a blog that functions similarly to things like Animal Planet has hit upon the right formula for communicating with the public. What is lost/gained from taking a more casual approach to communicating science?

     Reviewing these blogs brings me back to the original question I posed: What is the purpose of a science blog? That question could be more productively rephrased as: What should science blogging do? These blogs show that blogs can interpret primary sources of scientific results, make science more interesting, illustrate why doing science matters, give insights into the process of science, and  simply share enthusiasm for different topics in science. Are all of these pursuits worthwhile? Which approach is most effective? Most importantly, are blogs even the correct approach to communicating with the public?

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Two approaches to the same subject

Two accounts of the same events are considered here: one written by a scientist and the other by a wildlife journalist. Both address the ecological impacts of the removal and subsequent re-introduction of Yellowstone Park wolves.

The Wolf Effect

    Throughout this piece, the author gives a decent introduction to some influential ideas in community ecology (e.g., density- vs. trait-mediated effects and trophic cascades, though it was odd not to see mention of  keystone species or top-down vs. bottom-up control of ecosystem function.). While the idea of a food web may be blindingly obvious to your average ecologist, the general public could probably stand to have this concept illustrated and reinforced (I know my father always wants to know what an organism "does" in the world, what its "purpose" is). To this end, the author did an excellent job connecting of wolves to the entire Yellowstone community: elk, bears, coyotes, pronghorn, foxes, rodents, ravens, owls, beetles, trees, and grasses are all impacted by wolves in interesting and sometimes unexpected ways.

    There was, however, one organism's interactions with wolves that I thought the author could have explored more thoroughly. Why did the wolf extirpation happen in the first place? The shooting of the buffalo hints that this action may have been driven by the economic concerns of local ranchers. Human concerns about elk over-population and excessive grazing are understandable, but the author seemed puzzled by the fact that people then became concerned about the dwindling elk population. Could it be that the wolf re-introduction renewed pressure on livestock? I found the lack of coverage on this topic disappointing, especially since humans are the real keystone species driving these trophic cascades.

    The ever-present issue of climate change, and its role in explaining natural phenomena, was treated fairly well here. The author made it clear how if a year was wetter or drier than average, the elk faced adverse conditions. Mechanistic explanations of why precipitation is so important to the elk help to clarify the potential impacts of climate change, and I was glad to see the author devote some time to these descriptions. Overall, I think the average non-scientist would come away understanding that the increased frequency of extreme conditions predicted by current climate change models are bound to have measurable impacts on this ecosystem.

The straightforward, informative style and meaningful content of this piece lead me to believe it was written by a scientist.

Valley of Fear

    Because I had read The Wolf Effect first (it was shorter and had pictures!), I had already decided that this article was written by a wildlife journalist. My belief in this matter was confirmed on every page: the language used was far more poetic and I found the article harder to read. Although the same events were being described, the author placed significantly more focus on individual scientists, their thoughts, and their actions. A slew of direct quotations filled some gaps left by The Wolf Effect: How did the scientists figure this stuff out? How were their hypotheses regarded by their peers? This kind of writing likely gives more life to how the public perceives the pursuit of knowledge, but it wasn't something I found lacking in the first article. However, this approach may be more effective at reaching the public.

    An interesting point that wasn't given enough attention was the public reaction to the scientists' claim that wolves were driving these patterns. The author describes that when research reveals a new "overarching paradigm", people will resist it so long as they have a single point of contention with it. This seems to be the case with the current illogical debates in our society about climate change and evolution. To those who are not scientifically trained, a mountain of evidence can be toppled by one seemingly incongruous fact, even if the theory is fully capable of accommodating that fact. The next sentence in this section raises the possibility that people may be "ideologically opposed" to the results of a scientific study. This certainly seems to be the case with climate change and evolution, but how this fits with the wolf re-introduction is unclear. Probing further into why the public meets these ideas with such resistance may reveal the true shortcomings in the attempt of scientists to communicate their findings.

    I was pleased to see that the author took the time to consult some primary literature. Anyone who has the dual skills of being able to understand scientific publications and effectively convey the results and implications to a non-scientific audience is an asset in the battle to get everyone onto the same page. Perhaps it would be advantageous for research institutions to hire publicists that could serve this function...

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Communicating ecological issues with the public

Despite the fact that I'm only a graduate student, I've already participated in public outreach events designed to increase public understanding and interest in biology. The benefits of such activities are clear to me, so Pace et al. (2010) was an easy sell. I suppose there are a number of "old guard" ecologists out there who do not appreciate this other aspect of being a scientist, and perhaps they are the target audience for this article. I found the ideas presented by Groffman et al. (2010) more interesting, though I think they were less effective in making a case for their arguments.

The authors discuss the relationship between the public and science by using climate change as their primary example. I wonder if this is the most fruitful approach. What about other, less politicized, ecological issues (eutrophication, loss of biodiversity, habitat fragmentation, pesticide resistance, etc.)? Furthermore, not all ecologists study climate change. The authors did not have to choose a single ecological issue to structure their paper around, and I think their case would have been stronger if they had used multiple examples of current challenges in environmental science.

The authors stress the importance of communicating with the public in new ways (e.g., new models, frameworks, tools) but they ignore a major shortcoming of how science is communicated. They state, "...most people learn about science not through formal schooling, but through informal sources, such as the media...". If the purpose of formal schooling is not to teach the public about science, then what is it for? The authors suggest that the solution to this problem is to reach the public via these informal sources. While this is probably a useful pursuit, it completely ignores the root of the problem. We are failing to teach the public about science while they are in school.

I hope the effort that is being put into finding more effective ways for scientists to communicate with the public is at least matched (but ideally exceeded) by efforts to improve science education in our schools.